The Invite Explained: Olivia Wilde’s A24 Dinner Party Comedy, Marriage & Desire | Feminist Movie Review
The Invite is principally concerned with agency in intimate partnerships and asks whether two people can choose to reimagine their relationship rather than abandon it. I describe a married couple whose life has narrowed and who, confronted by vivacious neighbors, must face buried desires, missed bids for connection, and the erosion of being seen. We unpack how the film treats sex as a symptom of inattention rather than the root cause, and how Angela’s artistic erasure and Joe’s preserved grief function as the emotional engines of the conflict. I argue that the upstairs couple serve as a mirror or projection that forces honest confrontation, and that the film deliberately leaves the final outcome ambiguous so the audience must decide whether repair or rupture is the rightful path. We conclude that the movie elevates conversation, observation, and quiet transformation over spectacle, and that its ending marks the beginning of a new, more candid relationship configuration rather than a simple restoration of the old one. I present a sustained interrogation of Olivia Wilde’s The Invite, where I trace the evening’s arc from brittle domestic ritual to a reckoning that forces the protagonists to confront their mutual inattentions. I recount the plot with precision: Joe and Angela, a married couple whose intimacy has calcified, host their neighbors Pina and Hawk for dinner; what begins with humor and social discomfort evolves into a candid therapy session and a short-lived partner swap that collapses not because of sex but because the couple have ceased to witness each other. I emphasize Wilde’s declared theme of agency and the film’s insistence that relationships can be reimagined, and I foreground the way the narrative privileges conversation over spectacle, letting speech function as the primary locus of action and revelation. I argue that the film’s moral core locates desire and discontent within inattention rather than betrayal. I describe key scenes—the improvised kiss, Pina’s perimenopause monologue, Joe unlocking his piano—and explain how they serve the film’s thesis: sex is symptomatic, attention is curative. Our closing assessment asks whether Joe and Angela will remain spouses or become newly honest companions. I render the conclusion ambiguous but ultimately hopeful, suggesting that the evening destroys the old version of their marriage and opens a space, at the piano, for a newly truthful relationship, whether romantic or platonic.
Takeaways:
- I argue that The Invite centers on a failing marriage and the possibility of reinvention.
- We emphasize Olivia Wilde's intention to foreground agency, choice, and honest conversation within relationships.
- I observe that the non‑monogamy element functions as a mirror for the married couple, not as the main conflict.
- We note a Jungian reading in which Pina and Hawk act as projections of Joe and Angela's buried desires and talents.
- I critique the film's feminist arc because Angela's restoration is framed through joining Joe's music rather than through independent artistic reclamation.
- We describe the film's craft choices: shooting on 35mm, distinct camera languages, thrifted set design, and rehearsal led to organic performances.
- I highlight that silence and the solo cello score were used to reflect nerves and to let scenes breathe rather than to overwhelm them.
- We conclude the ending is intentionally ambiguous, asking the audience to decide whether the couple rebuilds together or becomes honest friends.
Transcript
Millennial Moving Mob.
Speaker A:Cue the lights, let it roll.
Speaker A:Yeah, we're diving in it all, every frame, every job.
Speaker A:Breaking it down with the Mob Film analysis.
Speaker A:Yeah, we go deeper.
Speaker B:Hi.
Speaker B:Hello.
Speaker B:Welcome.
Speaker B:I'm Amanda Blossom and this is Millennial Movie Mob, the podcast where we overthink movies on purpose.
Speaker B:Today we're RSVPing to the invite.
Speaker B: The: Speaker B:Spoiler warning.
Speaker B:I do not know how to talk about a movie without spoiling it.
Speaker B:We're covering the whole thing, ending included.
Speaker B:If you haven't seen the invite yet, pause it, go watch it, ideally with a couple of friends, and come back.
Speaker B:Edward Norton says it should be a double date movie minimum.
Speaker B:And honestly, he's right.
Speaker B:The Invite is about a married couple whose relationship is hanging by a thread.
Speaker B:They invite their loud, very sexually adventurous neighbors over for dinner.
Speaker B:Over one disastrous night in a San Francisco apartment.
Speaker B:The evening spirals into confessions, a proposition, and a reckoning with whether there may marriage is already over.
Speaker B:Okay, shoes off at the door, please.
Speaker B:Let's go in first.
Speaker B:The Players.
Speaker B:The Invite is directed by Olivia Wilde.
Speaker B:It's her third feature after Booksmart and Don't Worry Darling and she also stars in it.
Speaker B:Seth Rogen plays Joe, a burnt out music teacher and former punk singer.
Speaker B:Wilde has called this the best work of his career.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde plays Angela, Jo's wife, a stay at home mom who went to art school.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde didn't even want to be in it.
Speaker B:Her co stars pressured her into the role.
Speaker B:Penelope Cruz plays Pina, the upstairs neighbor and a therapist and sexologist.
Speaker B:She is magnetic in this.
Speaker B:Edward Norton plays Hawk, Pina's partner and ex fire captain, fire fighter.
Speaker B:He's hilarious and weirdly sweet and he even wrote one of his own monologues.
Speaker B:Okay, the night the short version.
Speaker B:It opens on young Joe and Angela laughing at a piano, madly in love.
Speaker B:And then an Oscar Wilde quote.
Speaker B:One should always be in love.
Speaker B:That is the reason one should never marry.
Speaker B:Cut to years later and Joe is a miserable music teacher.
Speaker B:While Angela races around San Francisco prepping a dinner party.
Speaker B:She is springing on Joe.
Speaker B:Pina and Hawk arrive mid fight, flan in hand.
Speaker B:The evening is a disaster.
Speaker B:A burned souffle, a vegan guest facing a mountain of jamon, a lost wine opener, and Angela's lie about when she planned it all.
Speaker B:The couple split up.
Speaker B:Jo smoking a joint with Pina and Angela giving Hawk the apartment tour.
Speaker B:And both of them get the kind of attention they haven't gotten from each other in years.
Speaker B:Then the reveal.
Speaker B:The noises upstairs are sex parties and the neighbors came to invite Joe and Angela.
Speaker B:They agree to swap partners and it falls apart almost immediately.
Speaker B:It turns into a therapy session.
Speaker B:Pina tells them she thinks their relationship friendship is over.
Speaker B:And then she and Hawk quietly disappear.
Speaker B:The movie ends with Joe playing his piano for the first time in years and Angela sitting down, resting her head on his shoulder beside him.
Speaker B:So what was Olivia Wilde trying to do with this movie?
Speaker B:She's talked about it a lot, and her own words are the best place to start.
Speaker B:She said the reason that I wanted to make this film is because it was a chance to have a real conversation about relationships and love.
Speaker B:Her big message is agency.
Speaker B:She said it's really important to get across that you have agency in your life, you have choice, and within your relationships, you have the opportunity to reimagine that relationship with the person you love.
Speaker B:She told RogerEbert.com that she actually hopes the film inspires arguments.
Speaker B:She also said the conversations are the action scenes.
Speaker B:She told NPR that when we meet Angela, she's existing on a very powerful fault line of tension, and it was important to her to show that even the most loving couples fight.
Speaker B:Pina and Hawk, she said, show Angela and Joe that there is beauty in rupture and repair.
Speaker B:She leaned on the relationship therapist Esther Perel, who consulted on the film.
Speaker B:Wilde said the core of every great relationship is honesty and communication, but that doesn't mean total transparency.
Speaker B:It's also personal.
Speaker B:She told Time her character had an experience of heartbreak that was not foreign to me.
Speaker B:Time's headline quoted her calling it a relief to rip my heart out of my chest.
Speaker B:And it was a process experiment.
Speaker B:She chose this story because it was simple enough to finally let her make a film the way she'd always dreamed.
Speaker B:Rather rehearse it, workshop it, shoot it in order on the film and make it a living, breathing piece of material.
Speaker B:It's also a love letter to the filmmakers who shaped her.
Speaker B:She calls it a tip of the hat to Mike Nichols.
Speaker B:At the very end, there's a title card dedicated to Diane.
Speaker B:That's Diane Keaton.
Speaker B:Wilde said she couldn't have made it without the influence Keaton had on her as an actor and as a person.
Speaker B:Now let's talk about where Wilde comes from as a director.
Speaker B: Her debut was Booksmart in: Speaker B:Two overachieving best friends, Molly and Amy, played by Beanie Feldstein and Caitlin Dever, realize on the night before graduation that they spent all of high school studying while everyone else had fun.
Speaker B:So they try to cram four years of partying into one night fun.
Speaker B:People love to joke that Booksmart lives in the Superbad universe.
Speaker B:Booksmart got called the female Superbad from day one and Beanie Feldstein is Jonah Hill's little sister.
Speaker B:And Jonah Hill starred in Superbad.
Speaker B:Fan Theory is Molly secretly Seth's little sister.
Speaker B:And here's where it gets even better.
Speaker B:Superbad was co written by Seth Rogen, so in a way the Invite closes the loop.
Speaker B:Wilde made her female Superbad and now she's directing the guy who wrote the original.
Speaker B: n came Don't Worry Darling in: Speaker B:I loved it and I'll defend it forever.
Speaker B: Florence Pugh plays Alice, a: Speaker B:Alice is a surgeon.
Speaker B:Her husband, played by Harry Styles, trapped her in a fantasy where she's a housewife and Wilde said Chris Pine's cult leader was inspired by Jordan Peterson.
Speaker B:I love how the ending recontextualizes everything you just watched.
Speaker B:Don't Worry, Darling got buried under its press tour.
Speaker B:The public dispute over Shia LaBeouf leaving the cast reported tension with Florence Pugh, the viral Spitgate video at Venice Wild being served, custody papers on stage at Cinemacon, and non stop tabloid coverage of her relationship with Harry Styles.
Speaker B:It landed at 38 on Rotten Tomatoes and Wilde told Variety that 38 liberated her to make the Invite.
Speaker B:The the movie that got dismissed is the reason she could make the one getting her taken seriously.
Speaker B:When you line up all three films, they make a trilogy.
Speaker B:Booksmart is two high school girls who gave up fun for ambition.
Speaker B:The Trap is a self imposed rule book.
Speaker B:The Structure is one wild night and it ends with best friends who love each other parting ways.
Speaker B: Don't Worry darling is a: Speaker B:The Trap is a man's fantasy world, The Structure is a looping fake paradise and it ends with her escape.
Speaker B:The Invite is a modern stay at home mom who gave up art for family.
Speaker B:The Trap is an ordinary marriage.
Speaker B:The Structure is one disastrous dinner and it ends with a reinvent or part.
Speaker B:Booksmart and the Invite are mirror images.
Speaker B:Molly gave up living for achievement, Angela gave up achievement for living.
Speaker B:Same regret, opposite directions and Book Smart ends with the best friends who love each other heading in different directions, which is almost exactly Wilde's first reading of the Invite's ending.
Speaker B:They break up but they stay best Friends Don't Worry Darling and the Invite tell the same story at different volumes.
Speaker B:In one, a man literally erases a woman's career for his fantasy.
Speaker B:In the other, the same thing happens with no villain at all.
Speaker B:Nobody locked Angela in.
Speaker B:Her life just quietly shrank into throw pillows and lamps.
Speaker B:That's scarier, honestly, because that's what happens to real women.
Speaker B:No simulation required.
Speaker B:And the biggest difference?
Speaker B:Twist versus ambiguity.
Speaker B:Don't Worry Darling hits you with a reveal.
Speaker B:The Invite has no twist, just two people being honest and an ending you have to decide for yourself.
Speaker B:Wild says the ending was only possible because indie film gave her the autonomy.
Speaker B:My take is Don't Worry Darling was the loud version of a quiet truth.
Speaker B:The Invite is Wild telling the same truth at a volume people can finally hear.
Speaker B:Angela is Alice without the simulation.
Speaker B:Now we have to talk about ethical non monogamy because this movie gets a lot of credit and a little side eye for how it handles it.
Speaker B:First, a quick vocabulary note.
Speaker B:Because it matters.
Speaker B:Non monogamy is the umbrella under it.
Speaker B:You've got open relationships, swinging, polyamory and more sex Parties and partners swapping are closer to swinging or an open relationship Compersion and deep emotional honesty are more polyamorous ideas.
Speaker B:The movie kind of mixes them together.
Speaker B:So I'm going to say non monogamy.
Speaker B:To be fair to everybody, what critics say it gets right, it doesn't punish.
Speaker B:Peanut and Hawk.
Speaker B:For decades, Hollywood treated any couple outside monogamy as either a joke or a cautionary tale headed for disaster.
Speaker B:This movie lets the non monogamous couple be the most appealing people in the room.
Speaker B:Little White Lies called it a poly rom com where the joke is on the monogamous for once.
Speaker B:And that's true.
Speaker B:The comedy isn't Peanut and Hawk.
Speaker B:It's Joe and Angela, the boring married couple practically drooling over the sex party stories.
Speaker B:A writer for the Guardian who practices non monogamy praised the way it explains the vocabulary without lecturing.
Speaker B:The compersion.
Speaker B:Conversation is a great example.
Speaker B:I learned something.
Speaker B:What critics push back on is some say the movie gets cold feet.
Speaker B:Fanbolt pointed out that the marketing dangles an orgy the film has no intention of delivering.
Speaker B:The trailer even used Ring My Bell, which isn't in the actual movie.
Speaker B:The film sold a sex disco romp and delivered a solo cello and a lot of uncomfortable silence.
Speaker B:Others say it treats something ordinary like it's shocking.
Speaker B:One critic basically said a couple hooking up with another couple.
Speaker B:For some people that's a Tuesday and there's an ethics problem.
Speaker B:Pina is a therapist dating her former patient, a grieving widower.
Speaker B:That's a real red flag, not just a lifestyle quirk.
Speaker B:We'll come back to that in the Jungian lens.
Speaker B:Here's where I land.
Speaker B:I don't think this is a movie about non monogamy at all.
Speaker B:It's a movie about monogamy and Peanut and Hawk are the mirror.
Speaker B:One review put it perfectly.
Speaker B:This isn't arguing open relationships are liberating or destructive.
Speaker B:The real temptation isn't sex.
Speaker B:It's comparison connects right back to everything else.
Speaker B:Jo and Angela say yes so fast, not because they want group sex, they want to be wanted.
Speaker B:And the swap fails because you can't outsource intimacy you've stopped building at home.
Speaker B:One more fun little detail.
Speaker B:The kiss between Angela and Pina was improvised.
Speaker B:Cruz just went for it.
Speaker B:And Wilde was so shocked, she turned her head and looked straight into the camera lens.
Speaker B:She said her mind went blank and her first thought was a film camera joke, hair in the gate.
Speaker B:And that take was in the movie.
Speaker B:Before we get into lenses, let's talk about where this story comes from.
Speaker B:Because it's got a wild family tree.
Speaker B:It started as a play.
Speaker B: the neighbor upstairs, around: Speaker B: In: Speaker B:That story has been remade over and over.
Speaker B:Italy, Switzerland, France, South Korea, and there's reportedly a Belgian Dutch version on the way.
Speaker B:The Invite is the American version.
Speaker B:That many remakes tells you this premise speaks to something universal.
Speaker B:Two couples, one dinner, and a marriage that's run out of air.
Speaker B:In the original, the couple is Julio and Anna, played by Javier Camara and Griselda Cicilani.
Speaker B:They've been together over 15 years.
Speaker B:They don't touch each other anymore and fighting is just their normal.
Speaker B:The neighbors are Salva and Lara, played by Alberto San Juan and Belle Anguesta.
Speaker B:He's a firefighter, she's a psychologist.
Speaker B:Sound familiar?
Speaker B:Hawk is an ex firefighter and Pina is a therapist and sexologist.
Speaker B:Same bones.
Speaker B:The biggest flip for me is the age.
Speaker B:In the Spanish version, the sexy neighbors are younger than the hosts.
Speaker B:In the Invite, Pina and Hawk are older.
Speaker B:That changes everything.
Speaker B:It's no longer look at those young people and their energy.
Speaker B:It's these people are further down the road than us.
Speaker B:They've been divorced, widowed, they've lived and they are still choosing aliveness.
Speaker B:That makes Joe and Angela's stagnation feel like a choice, not an age thing.
Speaker B:It's also why Pina's perimenopause speech works so well.
Speaker B:That's a woman past 50 talking about her body and her desire, and she's the sexiest person in the room.
Speaker B:More on that later.
Speaker B:The ending is the other huge difference between the original.
Speaker B:In Sentimental, the couple stays together.
Speaker B:Wilde said the end of her film is different from the original movie and very different from their script.
Speaker B:She and Seth Rogen were still workshopping it until the very last minute.
Speaker B:And here's my favorite the idea for the new ending reportedly came from Rashida Jones and Will McCormick watching Sentimental for the first time, and McCormick guessing wrong about what was going to happen.
Speaker B:His wrong guess became the American ending.
Speaker B:I love that a misread became the whole emotional thesis.
Speaker B:Critics have mostly been kind to the remake, which is rare.
Speaker B:The Cosmic Circus called it a rare remake that surpasses the original, partly because Wild gave it a real visual language by shooting on 35 millimeter film.
Speaker B:A Spanish film site, Espinoff said it has so much personality you almost forget it's a remake, and pointed out that the ending trades reconciliation sex for something more intimate and personal.
Speaker B:To be fair, some fans of the original aren't into it.
Speaker B:A few find the American version more hand holding, more explain it to you.
Speaker B:Full disclosure, I haven't seen the original yet.
Speaker B:It's on my list.
Speaker B:If you've seen it, tell me how it compares.
Speaker B:But for me, the changes are the point older neighbors, a woman's backstory, and an ending that refuses to tie a bow.
Speaker B:That's where Wild made it hers.
Speaker B:Okay, you know it's coming.
Speaker B:Let's put on our young glasses and the first question everyone's asking Are Peanut and Hawk even real?
Speaker B:There's a popular theory that they're figments of Joe and Angela's imagination projections, and I went looking for proof that Olivia Wilde endorsed that.
Speaker B:I'll be honest, I found a lot of claims floating around online, but nothing solid.
Speaker B:What she has actually said is that the ending is totally up to the audience to decide.
Speaker B:So let's look at the evidence the movie gives us.
Speaker B:Peanut and Hawk vanish without a goodbye.
Speaker B:We never see them interact with anyone outside of Joe and Angela.
Speaker B:They show up exactly when the marriage needs a reckoning and they leave the second the truth gets spoken.
Speaker B:But then there's the flan dish.
Speaker B:Pina asks for it back, and Joe and Angela are rinsing it when the neighbors disappear.
Speaker B:The dish is the one physical Thing left behind.
Speaker B:It's proof they were there.
Speaker B:Or is it a Jungian analysis named Joel Crichton, who writes a substack called the Story, Always Thinks and wrote a book called Youngian Shakespeare, wrote a reading of this film that I loved.
Speaker B:His take is that Pina and Hawk are not quite imaginary and not quite real either.
Speaker B:Psychologically, they're projections of Joe and Angela.
Speaker B:Quick refresher on projection.
Speaker B:In Jungian terms, we often see qualities in other people before we can recognize them in ourselves.
Speaker B:Other people become symbols for the parts of us we haven't claimed yet.
Speaker B:So what are Joe and Angela projecting?
Speaker B:Everything they've buried.
Speaker B:Vitality, curiosity, desire, the willingness to change.
Speaker B:Look at what the neighbors do.
Speaker B:Pina sees Joe's messy office and calls it creativity.
Speaker B:The exact part of himself he's locked away.
Speaker B:Hawk sees Angela's eye for design, the exact talent she stopped believing in.
Speaker B:And Angela's window.
Speaker B:She's been walking naked past it, hoping to be seen.
Speaker B:Hawk is literally the one who sees her.
Speaker B:They're carrying the parts of Jo and Angela that Jo and Angela won't carry themselves.
Speaker B:And Creighton points out something that makes total sense.
Speaker B:Once you hear it, they're intensely present while they want something from you.
Speaker B:And then they evaporate.
Speaker B:That's how projections work.
Speaker B:When you finally see the thing in yourself, you don't need the other person to carry it anymore.
Speaker B:Crichton also says the film flashes a copy of the Book of Symbols on screen, basically winking at you to read the whole thing.
Speaker B:Symbolically.
Speaker B:I didn't see it, but I'm sure it's there.
Speaker B:Here's a reading of my own.
Speaker B:The people upstairs think about it.
Speaker B:For the whole first act, there are noises through the ceiling.
Speaker B:Life happening just out of sight.
Speaker B:Pleasure you can hear but can't reach.
Speaker B:That is the unconscious.
Speaker B:And tonight the unconscious literally comes downstairs and sits at the dinner table.
Speaker B:Now let's talk Persona, which in young is the mask we should show the world.
Speaker B:Angela's Persona is the perfect hostess.
Speaker B:The podcast reset trick three outfit changes.
Speaker B: The souffle, the: Speaker B:Her mask has fused with the house.
Speaker B:There's barely any Angela left.
Speaker B:Underneath, Joe's Persona is the curmudgeon, and under the grumpy is grief.
Speaker B:The locked piano, the band record nobody's allowed to hear.
Speaker B:An office Angela isn't allowed to renovate.
Speaker B:He's not mean.
Speaker B:He's in mourning.
Speaker B:Then the symbols.
Speaker B:There are mirrors everywhere in this movie, and it's deliberate.
Speaker B:Co writer Will McCormick credited Wilde with creating a running motif of mirrors and what they reflect about the four people.
Speaker B:The production designer said the mirrors were integral to the story about how we move ourselves in our relationships.
Speaker B:A movie full of mirrors, about people who can't see themselves.
Speaker B:There's the single pane glass that would shatter with a little heat in an apartment that's very cold.
Speaker B:There's a wall Angela knocked down between two rooms.
Speaker B:And the characters keep standing on the line where it used to be.
Speaker B:Doorways, hallways, thresholds everywhere.
Speaker B:In Jungian terms, liminal spaces are where transformation happens.
Speaker B:This apartment is basically one big threshold.
Speaker B:But Crichton is not a peanut, and Hawk, Stan and I appreciate that.
Speaker B:He says their sense of being above it all hides their own shadow.
Speaker B:Pina dated a former patient, a grieving widower, which he calls an ethical breach.
Speaker B:And Hawk is carrying an old self, Howard, a man who shut down his late wife's desires.
Speaker B:So even the projection isn't perfect.
Speaker B:Your shadow comes with its own shadow.
Speaker B:Very young.
Speaker B:And then the ending.
Speaker B:Through this lens.
Speaker B:Joe sits down at the piano he's kept locked away and plays.
Speaker B:Angela joins him.
Speaker B:The part of him that was split off comes back in young would call that a step toward integration.
Speaker B:And Pina's line that sometimes you can have a new relationship with the same person is basically transformation without leaving.
Speaker B:You don't have to burn the house down.
Speaker B:You have to become someone new inside it, real or not real.
Speaker B:Honestly, I think it doesn't matter whether Peanut and Hawk ate that charcuterie or not.
Speaker B:They did their job.
Speaker B:They were the mirror.
Speaker B:And once Joe and Angela finally looked, the mirror could leave.
Speaker B:Okay, confession time.
Speaker B:I have a bias in this one, and I'm going to own it.
Speaker B:I was Team Angela from the very first shirt change.
Speaker B:And I think I know why I've been Angela.
Speaker B:I know what it's like to pour yourself into making something beautiful and have the person closest to you not notice, to feel invisible in your own home.
Speaker B:I've been in a relationship where my dreams weren't believed in, where I started shrinking my own ambitions before anyone else could.
Speaker B:So, yes, I'm biased.
Speaker B:But I'm going to argue that my bias is actually the reading this film is asking for.
Speaker B:Because our culture, and honestly, even this movie, tends to treat a man's lost dream as a tragedy and a woman's lost dream as background.
Speaker B:Let's start with the evidence.
Speaker B:Joe's lost dream gets a shrine.
Speaker B:He Used to be in a band.
Speaker B:A punk singer.
Speaker B:There's the record, the piano, a whole office full of books and music that nobody is allowed to touch.
Speaker B:His grief gets its own room.
Speaker B:Angela's last dream.
Speaker B:She went to art school.
Speaker B:And when Hawk is on the apartment tour, he finds one of her photos in the hallway.
Speaker B:It's not hanging, it's on the floor turned backwards, facing the wall.
Speaker B:Hawk flips it around and he's genuinely impressed.
Speaker B:He asks if it's by some famous photographer and Angela says, no, that's me.
Speaker B:He asks if she works as a photographer and she says no.
Speaker B:She went to art school a million years ago and got a degree that she did.
Speaker B:And I quote, literally nothing with.
Speaker B:Listen to that.
Speaker B:She dismisses herself before anyone else gets the chance.
Speaker B:That's what happens when you're taken for granted long enough.
Speaker B:You start doing their job for them.
Speaker B:And the photo is framed at some point.
Speaker B:She cared enough to frame it.
Speaker B:She meant to hang it.
Speaker B:And it's just been sitting there between keeping and giving up.
Speaker B:Which is exactly where Angela lives this entire movie.
Speaker B:How the film treats their pain side by side.
Speaker B:Joe had a band, a record and a piano and mourns them out loud.
Speaker B:Angela has an art degree and a photo backwards on the hallway floor.
Speaker B:Joe has a whole office, kept like a shrine.
Speaker B:Angela has the whole apartment, which still isn't hers.
Speaker B:How they cope.
Speaker B:Joe with anger, sarcasm and shutting people out.
Speaker B:Angela with overworking, people pleasing.
Speaker B:And a Xanax.
Speaker B:How it reads.
Speaker B:Joe comes off as a wounded artist.
Speaker B:Angela comes off as frantic, a bundle of nerves.
Speaker B:And who notices?
Speaker B:The opening is built to win our sympathy for Joe.
Speaker B:Angela is only noticed by a stranger.
Speaker B:Hawk.
Speaker B:Joe's misery reads as depth.
Speaker B:Angela's misery reads as a punchline.
Speaker B:The shirt changes.
Speaker B:The souffle, panic, Gollum at the oven.
Speaker B:And I laughed at all of it.
Speaker B:That's my point.
Speaker B:Her suffering is staged as a comedy.
Speaker B:His is staged as a tragedy.
Speaker B:When the tequila comes out and Angela takes a Xanax.
Speaker B:Come on, have you seen her?
Speaker B:She's been carrying this night entirely by herself.
Speaker B:Now look at what Joe can't receive.
Speaker B:He has the privilege, she has the labor.
Speaker B:He hates the foldable bike she bought him.
Speaker B:He downplays everything she's done to make the house a home.
Speaker B:His one compliment about her shirt comes too late to count.
Speaker B:And at the end, he literally asks what she does all day.
Speaker B:And here's the detail I didn't know until I dug in.
Speaker B:The costume designer imagined.
Speaker B:Angela buys Joe's clothes.
Speaker B:Even what he's wearing.
Speaker B:And he doesn't notice that either.
Speaker B:Then there's the validation.
Speaker B:Angela lights up at every single compliment and makes you kind of sad because none of it comes from Jo.
Speaker B:She gets emotional when Pina and Hawk compliment the apartment.
Speaker B:Jo says her three paint swatches all look the same.
Speaker B:A stranger gives every one of them a name.
Speaker B:A stranger turns her photo around.
Speaker B:Now the visual evidence, because Wilde built this into the whole look of the film.
Speaker B:The mint blouse matches the walls on purpose.
Speaker B:The costume designer Arianne Phillips dyed it to match.
Speaker B:And Wilde explained that it creates this almost subconscious effect of Angela having almost no identity beyond the home.
Speaker B:She said Angela gave up her dream of being an artist and so much of her life got lost to the surface of things.
Speaker B:The throw pillows and the lamps.
Speaker B:The production designer, Jade Healy, said she picked the blues and greens because she wanted Angela to feel like she's drowning under the stagnant weight of life.
Speaker B:And every piece of decor she can bring adds to the weight.
Speaker B:And the camera.
Speaker B:Angela's close ups are shot with longer lenses that squeeze the space and feel claustrophobic, like we're examining her.
Speaker B:So think about that.
Speaker B:Angela isn't seen by her husband, but she's scrutinized by the camera.
Speaker B:Being looked at is not the same as being seen.
Speaker B:Even the shoes.
Speaker B:Angela makes Joe take his shoes off, but Peanut and Hawk keep their boots on all night.
Speaker B:Wild's idea, as Philip put it.
Speaker B:Angela is barefoot and Joe is wearing pink socks.
Speaker B:The guests have boots and stature.
Speaker B:The hosts are exposed in their own home.
Speaker B:Now, I'm not going to pretend Angela is a saint because that weakens the argument.
Speaker B:She lied about when she planned the dinner and let Joe think he forgot.
Speaker B:She basically gaslit him.
Speaker B:She bosses him around with house rules and brushes off how he feels about the neighbors.
Speaker B:But here's the turn.
Speaker B:Her lies are small, anxious and controlling.
Speaker B:That's the behavior of someone who has lost power everywhere except over one dinner party.
Speaker B:Jo's coldness is the behavior of someone who has the power.
Speaker B:The inherited apartment, the protected grief and won't use it.
Speaker B:They're both wrong.
Speaker B:They are not equally powerful.
Speaker B:And then there's the window.
Speaker B:Angela walking naked past the window so Hawk will see her.
Speaker B:You could play that as scandal.
Speaker B:I read it as desperate.
Speaker B:It's the one desire she actually acted on herself.
Speaker B:And it's about being seen.
Speaker B:Is that agency or is it a symptom of being starved for attention?
Speaker B:I think it's both.
Speaker B:And then there's Pina, a woman over 50.
Speaker B:Openly sexual wise and not punished for any of it.
Speaker B:That's still rare on screen.
Speaker B:Her perimenopause speech wasn't even in the script.
Speaker B:Penelope Cruz fought for it.
Speaker B:She said, if Pina is going to talk about sex, she has to talk about this.
Speaker B:She improvised a bit with two olives from the charcuterie board while describing menopausal ovaries.
Speaker B:And Seth Rogen had no idea it was coming.
Speaker B:An actress put women's bodies at the center of the dinner table herself.
Speaker B:So here's where I land on the feminist lens.
Speaker B:Siding with Angela isn't unfair to Jo.
Speaker B:It's just checking the mirror.
Speaker B:The movie gives us every clue that she's been disappearing.
Speaker B:We just have to be willing to look.
Speaker B:Okay, the third and final lens.
Speaker B:And honestly, the one most of us will fill in our bones.
Speaker B:I the relationship lens.
Speaker B:My theory here is simple.
Speaker B:This movie is not really about sex.
Speaker B:It's about attention, resentment, and blame.
Speaker B:And the real question it's asking comes straight from the relationship therapist Esther Perel, who is actually a consultant on this film.
Speaker B:Can two people start a new relationship with each other, or is it time to part?
Speaker B:First, the quirks you loved become liabilities.
Speaker B:You know how it goes.
Speaker B:You get comfortable.
Speaker B:You start taking each other for granted, and the things that made you fall in love become things that drive you up the wall.
Speaker B:The music that made young Joe so magnetic at the piano.
Speaker B:It's now the bitterness Angela has to live around.
Speaker B:And Angela's gifts, like a thoughtful present, a beautiful home, become burdens to him.
Speaker B:He hates that foldable bike.
Speaker B:Even at work, he's checked out.
Speaker B:His notes to his students are basically, that was great, great work.
Speaker B:He's physically there and emotionally somewhere else.
Speaker B:Second, the missed bid for connection.
Speaker B:In relationship research, a bid is any little reach for attention, and this whole night is a parade of missed bids.
Speaker B:Angela spends the whole day buying cheeses, cured meats, flowers, and a rug for a guest she doesn't know is vegan, forgets the wine and texts Joe to grab some while he's biking uphill and can't read his phone.
Speaker B:She tries the podcast Reset, and they fall right back into the fight.
Speaker B:They can't find a wine opener without arguing, and she lights up at every compliment from strangers, which shows you how few she gets at home.
Speaker B:Third, the small lies.
Speaker B:Nobody in this marriage cheated.
Speaker B:What's eating it is the little dishonesties Angela says she told Joe about dinner days ago.
Speaker B:Lie.
Speaker B:As Mari would say, the lie detector determined that was a lie.
Speaker B:She planned it.
Speaker B:That Morning Joe denies going upstairs and banging on the neighbor's door one night.
Speaker B:And they literally have video.
Speaker B:Angela claims they never heard the sex noises.
Speaker B:Lie, and Jo's face says it all.
Speaker B:None of these are big betrayals.
Speaker B:They're the termites.
Speaker B:Fourth, sex is the symptom, not the cause.
Speaker B:They spend the first act arguing about Pina's orgasms, which they can hear through the ceiling.
Speaker B:And all that noise upstairs just highlights the sex that Joe and Angela aren't having.
Speaker B:One write up notes.
Speaker B:They haven't had sex in a year.
Speaker B:And the bedroom is the one room in that whole renovated apartment that's still unfinished.
Speaker B:The production designer said the bare bedroom was deliberate, and when they get the chance to swap, they say yes almost instantly and it collapses immediately.
Speaker B:Angela freezes with Hawk.
Speaker B:Jo throws out his back.
Speaker B:If sex were really the problem, the swap would have fixed something.
Speaker B:It doesn't, because the problem was never sex.
Speaker B:Fifth, blame versus responsibility.
Speaker B:This is the heart of Pina's therapy session.
Speaker B:She points out that each of them blames the other for their unhappiness.
Speaker B:She tells them how mean they are to each other.
Speaker B:Angela tells the story of the night they met, all the great sex they used to have.
Speaker B:So you know this was once a great relationship.
Speaker B:Then Pina asks which is better, happy parents who live apart or miserable parents who stay together for the kid.
Speaker B:She says we only get a few real chances at love.
Speaker B:That usually we move on to someone new, but sometimes we build a new relationship with the same person.
Speaker B:It's their call, but she thinks this one is over.
Speaker B:You could hear a pin drop.
Speaker B:And it lands even harder because they so clearly adore their 12 year old, who is at a sleepover at Sadie's where the mom is single, so no men in the house, according to Angela.
Speaker B:Angela is already dreading her leaving for college in six years.
Speaker B:Joe resents being told he decided to be miserable.
Speaker B:He feels like a failure.
Speaker B:His parents apartment, a job he hates.
Speaker B:And I can't help thinking if he reframed his perspective a little, he could find so much joy in that house.
Speaker B:Angela tries to tell him this and he can't hear it.
Speaker B:And earlier, sharing a joint with Pina, Joe asks her how she knew her own marriage was over.
Speaker B:He's already asking the question.
Speaker B:That's the moment you see the grand canyon of space between him and Angela.
Speaker B:Wilde had said the film is about the moment you realize you can no longer blame your unhappiness on each other and then decide, are you willing to start a new relationship with each other or is it time to part?
Speaker B:And sixth, rupture and repair.
Speaker B:Even the perfect couple fights.
Speaker B:When Pina and Hawk argue for the first time, we see they're human too.
Speaker B:Wild said it was important to her to show that even the most loving couples fight, that Pina and Hawk show Joe and Angela that there is beauty in rupture and repair.
Speaker B:She also said something I really love in another interview, that you have agency in your life, you have choice.
Speaker B:And within your relationships, you have the opportunity to reimagine that relationship with the person you love.
Speaker B:So what about the ending?
Speaker B:This is where it gets fun.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde and Seth Rogen totally disagreed about what happens to Joe and Angela.
Speaker B:Rogan thinks they stay together forever.
Speaker B:Wilde called him a softie.
Speaker B:Oh, sweet Seth.
Speaker B:She thought they broke up, but with this newfound respect for each other and became best friends.
Speaker B:And then more recently, she said she's gotten softer.
Speaker B:And now when she watches it, she thinks, wait a minute, maybe they do stay together.
Speaker B:She said it changes based on whatever you're going through in your life.
Speaker B:And I love that the ending is a mirror too.
Speaker B:What you see in it says something about you.
Speaker B:For me, I landed somewhere between Seth and Olivia.
Speaker B:I think the old relationship is dead.
Speaker B:That night killed it.
Speaker B:But at the piano, a new one begins.
Speaker B:Whether that new relationship is a marriage or a friendship, I don't know, but it's honest.
Speaker B:And honest is new for them.
Speaker B:The movie is basically a four person play.
Speaker B:So let's talk about this cast because Wilde called them her jazz quartet.
Speaker B: otally different cast back in: Speaker B:It was set up with Amy Adams, Paul Rudd and Tessa Thompson, directed by Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Ferris, the duo behind Little Miss Sunshine.
Speaker B: It stalled and in: Speaker B:Would you have watched this version?
Speaker B:I do love me some Paul Rudd.
Speaker B:Let's start with Seth Rogen as Joe.
Speaker B:You know him from Knocked Up, Superbad, and more recently the Studio, the Apple TV show he co created.
Speaker B:Wilde actually guest starred in an episode of the Studio playing a satirical version of herself.
Speaker B:Their history goes way back, though.
Speaker B:More than 20 years ago, Wilde did a table read for Knocked Up.
Speaker B:She didn't get the part and now here they are playing a married couple.
Speaker B:Wilde said this is Rogen's best work.
Speaker B: ance to Albert brooks and the: Speaker B:And honestly, Joe could have been unbearable.
Speaker B:Rogan makes him funny and sad at the Same time you want to shake him and hug him.
Speaker B:And Rogan's anecdotes because there are so many.
Speaker B:At the end of the shoot, he gave Wilde a note saying, I love screaming at you.
Speaker B:His own summary of his character, sexless, sad dad and filming his intimate scene with Penelope Cruz made him so awkward.
Speaker B:He kept thanking her and apologizing to her during the take, which he says is exactly how he'd act in real life.
Speaker B:He said the rehearsals got very personal very fast with the whole cast talking about their own marriages and that made the movie better.
Speaker B:Next.
Speaker B:Penelope Cruz as Pina Cruz is a four time Oscar nominee and a one time winner for Vicky.
Speaker B:Christina Barcelona.
Speaker B:She's an Alma Devar icon.
Speaker B:She actually decided to become an actress at 15 after seeing his film Tie Me Up, Tie Me down on the big screen.
Speaker B:And she is having a year.
Speaker B:She's in the Invite, La Bole Negra and the Bride.
Speaker B:If you haven't heard my episode on the Bride, go check it out.
Speaker B:The platinum bob Pina wears.
Speaker B:It's a wig and it was Cruz's idea.
Speaker B:Wilde actually disagreed with her at first.
Speaker B:Cruise told her she needed to depart from herself physically in order to transform.
Speaker B:And Wilde says the second she put it on, it was a full transformation.
Speaker B:Wilde also says most people don't realize Cruise is nothing like that character, which is exactly why the performance is so extraordinary.
Speaker B:Cruise says the rehearsals were 10 hours a day around a table, the four actors and the two writers.
Speaker B:And that's where she pushed for the perimenopause scene, plus the olives and her idea to sing Sade during a romantic scene.
Speaker B:Wilde says she's so madly in love with her.
Speaker B:She even joked about the shots where the camera just stays on Cruise the whole scene.
Speaker B:Sorry, Seth.
Speaker B:Then Edward Norton as Hawk.
Speaker B:Primal Fear, American History X, Fight Club, Birdman.
Speaker B:A guy known for intense intellectual roles.
Speaker B:And here he is lying on a rug talking about paint colors.
Speaker B:Joe is so openly rude to his face all night and Hawk just takes it.
Speaker B:Then tells him totally sincerely that he loves him and loves how honest he is about how he's feeling.
Speaker B:Norton had already seen the Spanish film and he said they saw themselves as the couple upstairs.
Speaker B:He'd worked with both Wilde and Rogen before and he and Cruz have been friends for almost 30 years.
Speaker B:He said the chemistry Wilde was proposing was too exciting to pass up.
Speaker B:Hawke's monologue in the third act about the origin of his name, the one Joe mocks.
Speaker B:Norton wrote it himself and Rogan's immediate response was improvised.
Speaker B:Norton described the shoot as unlike anything in his career.
Speaker B:He mainly because they shot it almost entirely in order so the actors could build momentum scene by scene.
Speaker B:And one of my favorite things, he said about why this movie works, the best stories are the ones where you recognize yourself.
Speaker B:You can laugh at a good joke, but when you recognize yourself in it, that's a completely different kind of laugh.
Speaker B:And finally, Olivia Wilde as Angela.
Speaker B:Here's the thing.
Speaker B:She didn't want to play her.
Speaker B:Wilde signed on only to direct.
Speaker B:She had imposter syndrome about acting next to these three.
Speaker B:She said she felt capable as a director, but acting was intimidating and she never would have suggested herself.
Speaker B:Rogan and Norton were texting each other like, how do we talk her into being in the movie?
Speaker B:Rogan said she kept sending them names of other actresses and he was like, why are we doing this?
Speaker B:There's an obvious person.
Speaker B:He admits they overtly pressured her and she ended up calling it the best experience of her career.
Speaker B:She said that until the invite, she had more confidence as a director than as an actor.
Speaker B:And can I point something out?
Speaker B:A woman who believed she didn't deserve the role, who had to be pushed by other people to step into the spotlight, a woman whose dream is turned backwards against a wall.
Speaker B:That's not lost on me.
Speaker B:Wilde's performance is so physical and so specific.
Speaker B:The shirt changes, the Golem crouch, the way her eyes go when the souffle burns.
Speaker B:One critic noted she conveys anxiety, shame and the desire to be appreciated almost entirely through her face.
Speaker B:That's the whole character.
Speaker B:So where do they each stand for awards?
Speaker B:Quick rundown as of early November, Penelope Cruz is the strongest acting vet.
Speaker B:She's in the top five for best supporting actress at the Oscars, a Gotham nominee and likely a Golden Globe nominee.
Speaker B:And she might be in the top five twice for La Bole Negra, too.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde is a strong Golden Globe contender for comedy musical actress and a real Oscar contender for best actress, both times trailing Julianne Moore in the debut.
Speaker B:Some pundits think she could land a directing nomination, too.
Speaker B:Edward Norton, a possible spoiler for supporting actor at the Oscars and on track for a SAG nomination.
Speaker B:Seth Rogen is a near lock at the Golden Globes for comedy musical actor, around 96 to 98% on Gold Derby at the Oscars.
Speaker B:Best actor is so stacked, he's a long shot, which honestly feels a little like Joe.
Speaker B:Now let's give it up for the people behind the camera, because this is where the movie's argument really lives.
Speaker B:This was made outside the studio system.
Speaker B:The budget was around 15 million.
Speaker B:Wilde wanted to shoot in Los Angeles in sequence with a lot of rehearsal, and that's not something studios love paying for.
Speaker B:After Sundance, A24 reportedly bought it for about 12 million after a 72 hour long bidding war.
Speaker B:And Wilde says she fought hard for it to get a real theatrical release instead of going straight into a streamer.
Speaker B: developing the remake back in: Speaker B:The process was six weeks total, including two weeks of rehearsal.
Speaker B:The four actors and the two writers sat around a table on an empty soundstage at Sunset Las Palmas Studios, the same soundstage where the pilot of I Love Lucy was filmed.
Speaker B:Wilde said that felt really meaningful.
Speaker B:Then they shot it in order on 35 millimeter film in 23 days and kept workshopping as they went.
Speaker B:Wilde said several of the greatest moments in the movie were written by the cast.
Speaker B:When she started filming, she didn't know exactly how it would end.
Speaker B:And that was by design.
Speaker B:The writers, Rashida Jones and Will McCormick, the duo behind Celeste and Jesse Forever.
Speaker B:Wilde says their script changed a lot through rehearsal and improvisation.
Speaker B:And they had a secret weapon.
Speaker B:Esther Perel consulted on the film and Wilde calls her the godmother of this conversation.
Speaker B:That line of pinas about a new relationship with the same person.
Speaker B:Wilde says, that's straight up Esther.
Speaker B:Here's something interesting.
Speaker B:I couldn't find accredited casting director anywhere.
Speaker B:Maybe it's there, but I didn't see it.
Speaker B:And that kind of makes sense because this cast basically assembled itself.
Speaker B:Wilde thought of Seth while imagining her own version of the original film.
Speaker B:Norton came for Wilde, Rogan and his 30 year friendship with Cruise.
Speaker B:And the cast cast wild cinematography.
Speaker B:Adam Newport Bera, who won an Emmy for shooting the studio and also shot the pilot of the Bear and episodes of Euphoria.
Speaker B:He met Wilde on the studio.
Speaker B:They shot on 3 perf 35mm with a Panavision camera and custom lenses built by Panavision's lens guru, Dan Sasaki.
Speaker B:Those lenses were originally designed for VistaVision and they showed up on set as unmarked silver barrels with handwritten markings.
Speaker B:Their big reference was Mike Nichols, who's afraid of Virginia Wolf.
Speaker B:They also looked at Antonioni's Le Clisse for reflections and odd angles.
Speaker B:Agnes Varda's Le Bonheur for color, Eric Roemer for making boring interiors feel magical.
Speaker B:And Hannah and her sisters.
Speaker B:And here's the part I love.
Speaker B:Every character gets their own camera language.
Speaker B:Jo and Angela are rarely in the same shot.
Speaker B:Their frames are flat, straight on, off center, with extra headroom, so they feel ungrounded.
Speaker B:Jo is often in wide shots, stressing his distance from Angela.
Speaker B:Angela gets the long lens close ups that feel claustrophobic, like we're examining her.
Speaker B:Pina is the only character filmed on Steadicam.
Speaker B:The camera follows her closely, so she feels seductive and brooding, like she's testing the boundaries of the space.
Speaker B:And Hawk is shot from slightly below on a normal lens, so he feels, in their words, heroically cool.
Speaker B:So the camera knows Joe and Angela are apart before they do.
Speaker B:One more cinematography note.
Speaker B:The original plan was to light only with the apartment's own lamps, inspired by Woody Allen's Husbands and Wives.
Speaker B:In tests, the shadows decided where the actors could stand, so they built soft lights into the ceiling and kept the lamps in frame.
Speaker B:That's why the lamp lighting up Jo's face like a campfire.
Speaker B:Horror story works so well.
Speaker B:And there was no shot list.
Speaker B:Every day, Wilde, Newport, Bera and the actors blocked the scenes together, guided by keywords like awkward, sexy, intimate and distant.
Speaker B:The production design, Jade Healy, who also designed Marriage Story, I, Tonya, A Ghost Story, the Green Knight and the Killing of the Sacred Deer.
Speaker B:Two films about marriages falling apart inside homes.
Speaker B:Marriage Story, and this one that's a career through line.
Speaker B:She designed the apartment as Angela.
Speaker B:She said, I became a version of Angela designing and decorating this apartment.
Speaker B:And instead of design magazines, she looked at Instagram, at ordinary women sharing their own maximalist decorating projects.
Speaker B:So Angela's art is real women's art.
Speaker B:She also said she didn't want to do a Nancy Meyers set.
Speaker B:No dream Home.
Speaker B:The floor plan is a Frankenstein of real San Francisco apartments she found on Zillow and Trulia.
Speaker B:And almost everything in it comes from Facebook, Marketplace, thrift stores and vintage shops like Angela's flea market.
Speaker B:Rug.
Speaker B:The set was thrifted.
Speaker B:Most of the art on the walls was painted by the cast and crew in a movie about a woman whose art is hidden.
Speaker B:The art on the walls was made by the people making the film.
Speaker B:The room tells the story.
Speaker B:Every room is renovated except the bedroom, left bare on purpose.
Speaker B:Healy said a wall with nothing on it says something.
Speaker B:Jo's office is the one room Angela hasn't touched, packed with books, records and the forbidden piano.
Speaker B:And at the end, Angela finally goes into that room and sits down next to him.
Speaker B:And here's a little feminist footnote.
Speaker B:Healy said that when the film premiered at Sundance, the early reviews barely mentioned the production design.
Speaker B:People only started appreciating it later.
Speaker B:The woman who made the home was overlooked at first, too.
Speaker B:Sound familiar?
Speaker B:The costumes are by Arianne Phillips, who also did Don't Worry Darling and has designed six world tours for Madonna.
Speaker B:Wilde calls her one of the greatest costume designers in film history.
Speaker B:For Angela, the mint blouse that matches the walls and a style modeled partly on Diane Keaton in Annie Hall.
Speaker B:Also looked at Charlotte Rampling, Romy Schneider and Jane Birkin.
Speaker B:And there's a real accident.
Speaker B:Angela's early striped blouse has a rip under the arm she discovers on camera.
Speaker B:That was a real vintage shirt.
Speaker B:And Wilde just improvised for Joe, a white tee, a rumpled faded denim shirt and pink socks.
Speaker B:His faded blue clashes just slightly with her mint.
Speaker B:Close in color, slightly off, just like their marriage.
Speaker B:For Pina, a suede jacket and red scarf that she peels off to a black blouse and bustier.
Speaker B:As the night goes on, her clothes come off in layers.
Speaker B:As the evening gets more honest.
Speaker B:Phillips loosely based her on Esther Perel and loaded her up with rings because Cruise talks with her hands.
Speaker B:For hawk jeans, a navy sweater, boots and a ring with a fireman insignia and a beaded bracelet with what Phillips called a feminine, fashionable quality.
Speaker B:A man secure enough to wear something soft.
Speaker B:The film had two editors.
Speaker B:Yorgos Mavropski, Yorgos Lanthimos's longtime editor in the Favorite and Poor Things.
Speaker B:Cut the assembly.
Speaker B:The Ant boys took over for most of the rest.
Speaker B:Wilde calls Yorgos Blackfish and says he's brilliant at finding the rhythm of unsettling dark comedy.
Speaker B:The first assembly ran about 3 hours and 10 minutes.
Speaker B:The final film is 107 minutes.
Speaker B:Some of the rules for cutting comedy keep a clean line between the setup and the punchline, with no new information in between.
Speaker B:And if a character is digging themselves into a hole, let them keep digging.
Speaker B:It gets funnier.
Speaker B:That's Jo all night.
Speaker B:Because everyone was improvising and talking over each other, Boys sometimes had to hunt through the other takes for a single word or syllable to splice in his philosophy.
Speaker B:Let them sing, Mavrop ceridis.
Speaker B:Cut that 32 minute stretch where the couple split up, which is longer than a lot of sitcom episodes.
Speaker B:Cutting back and forth between the two pairs lets you watch Joe and Angela come alive with someone else.
Speaker B:At the ending.
Speaker B:Boyce said that after two hours of Jo always having a comeback, the silence had to land at the very end.
Speaker B:They even cut Joe's lines from the kitchen scene because Joe has nothing left to say.
Speaker B:The only way he can communicate is the piano.
Speaker B:And they cut a scene where Joe and Angela were teaming up in the kitchen during the doorbell interruption because it broke the tension.
Speaker B:So the one scene of them working together as partners didn't make the movie.
Speaker B:The first time we really see them together is at that piano.
Speaker B:The score by Devonte Hines, also known as Blood Orange, who also scored Passing and the Queen and Slim, and it's a solo cello score.
Speaker B:Hines is a cellist himself, and when he found out the whole movie takes place in one apartment, he started thinking about plays and live instrumentation, like a musician sitting in the corner of the theater.
Speaker B:Wilde said she wanted the score to reflect the character's nerves, that the bow on the cello should feel like the bow on your actual nerves, like you're listening to their nervous systems.
Speaker B:I've heard critics call the score heavy handed.
Speaker B:I disagree, and here's my evidence.
Speaker B:The whole soundtrack album is only 23 minutes long across 26 short tracks.
Speaker B:The editors cut music back from earlier versions, and Wilde told an interviewer that she's afraid of silence, that she's leaned on music to hold attention in her earlier films, and that this movie was a learning experience in trusting silence.
Speaker B:That's growth.
Speaker B:The score isn't heavy handed, it's spiky on purpose and it knows when to shut up.
Speaker B:Okay, awards talk is the invite going to the Oscars because it is very much in the conversation.
Speaker B:First, a question I had going in as a remake was would this be up for best original or best adapted screenplay?
Speaker B:It's adapted.
Speaker B:It's based on the Spanish film which was based on the play.
Speaker B:So it falls under adapted and that's where every prediction list has it.
Speaker B:It's already racking up hardware.
Speaker B:The screenplay won a prize at the Nantucket Film Festival and the Gotham Awards just nominated it for best feature, best adapted screenplay and best supporting actress for Cruise.
Speaker B:Here's my quick scorecard.
Speaker B:Best picture about as safe as it gets for comedy musical at the Globes and the Oscar conversation around seventh or eighth in predictions.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde for acting strong at the Globes for comedy musical actress and a real Oscar contender for best actress trailing Julianne Moore at both.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde for directing is a of part possibility at both.
Speaker B:Seth Rogen is a near lock at the Globes for musical comedy actor and a long shot for the Oscars.
Speaker B:Penelope Cruz is a strong for supporting actress at the Globes and the likeliest Oscar acting nomination, Edward Norton is possible at the Globes and a possible spoiler for supporting actor at the Oscars, screenplay is strong at the Globes and a frontrunner for adapted screenplay at the Oscars.
Speaker B:The Golden Globes are this movie's best territory because they split drama and comedy variety projects.
Speaker B:Six nominations for the invite tied with La Bole Negra.
Speaker B:Gold Derby has had every one of its experts predicting a best comedy musical nomination and rogen sitting around 96 to 98% for comedy actor.
Speaker B:Variety literally said Rogen is destined to be an acting nominee.
Speaker B:Penelope Cruz is the Oscar story to watch.
Speaker B:Indiewire has called her the supporting actress frontrunner, but here's the twist.
Speaker B:She's competing against herself.
Speaker B:She's also in the running for La Bola Negra, and that's newly possible.
Speaker B:In May, the Academy got rid of a long standing rule that barred an actor from being nominated twice in the same category.
Speaker B:So Penelope Cruz could be nominated twice against herself in one category.
Speaker B:How iconic would that be?
Speaker B:Adapted screenplay is the other strong bet for Jones and McCormack.
Speaker B:Olivia Wilde for best actress is a real possibility, but Julianne Moore in the debut is the one to beat in most predictions.
Speaker B:Edward Norton, again possible for supporting actor.
Speaker B:And at the SAG Awards, now called the Actor Awards Gold Derby has the movie on track for an ensemble nomination.
Speaker B:Plus Wild Cruise and Norton individually.
Speaker B:And poor seth Rogen at SAG.
Speaker B:He's around number 14 in best actor for the Oscars.
Speaker B:One Gold Derby writer put it perfectly.
Speaker B:Sorry, Seth Rogen, but you won't be thanking Sal Saperstein in this year's absurdly stacked best actor category.
Speaker B:And here's my favorite angle on all this.
Speaker B:The Globes are likely to reward Rogen's comedy.
Speaker B:The Oscars might honor Wilde and leave Rogen out.
Speaker B:So in awards terms, this time the woman gets seen and the man doesn't.
Speaker B:Possibly.
Speaker B:Angela would be proud.
Speaker B:I would like to see this.
Speaker B:Nominated for best picture, director, adapted screenplay and Penelope Cruz for best actress.
Speaker B:All right, my take.
Speaker B:I loved this movie.
Speaker B:I laughed out loud so many times.
Speaker B:Hawk lying flat on the rug.
Speaker B:Angela crouched at the oven, guarding her souffle like Gollum with his precious.
Speaker B:Hawk totally serene, announcing he loves a contentious environment.
Speaker B:A vegan whose specialty is flan.
Speaker B:Hawk offering to eat Pina's meat, which honestly explains those orgasms.
Speaker B:Angela doing the most awkward dance, trying to stop Joe from confronting them about the noise.
Speaker B:Joe making it weird about Pina's age and the look on Joe's face when Angela swears they never heard a thing.
Speaker B:It is genuinely one of the funniest movies of the year.
Speaker B:And then it got under my skin because underneath all the awkward comedy, it's asking something really painful.
Speaker B:What happens when you stop seeing the person you love?
Speaker B:So what is this movie actually saying?
Speaker B:Let me try to put it plainly about women.
Speaker B:A woman's desire doesn't disappear when she becomes a wife and a mother.
Speaker B:And it goes underground.
Speaker B:Angela's desire to be seen, to make art, to be wanted, hasn't died.
Speaker B:It's been shoved into side channels, a window, a rug, a photograph turned toward the wall.
Speaker B:And the movie never shames her for any of it.
Speaker B:It doesn't punish Pina for being sexual past 50.
Speaker B:It lets menopause be talked about plainly at a dinner table.
Speaker B:That's the progressive part.
Speaker B:And about sex.
Speaker B:Sex is the symptom, not the problem.
Speaker B:Sex is not a thing you do.
Speaker B:It's a place you go.
Speaker B:Joe and Angela aren't sexless because they're bored with each other's bodies.
Speaker B:They're sexless because they stopped seeing each other.
Speaker B:Esther Perel's whole idea is that desire needs a little distance, a little mystery, the ability to see your partner as a separate, interesting person.
Speaker B:Hawk sees Angela that way.
Speaker B:In about five minutes, Joe sees her like part of the furniture about relationships.
Speaker B:Love rarely dies from some huge betrayal.
Speaker B:It dies from inattention and blame.
Speaker B:Nobody in this marriage cheated.
Speaker B:What's killing it is small lies, missed texts, an unopened bottle of wine, and two people who each think the other one is the reason they're unhappy.
Speaker B:So in one sentence, women lose themselves in marriage, not through cruelty, but through not being witnessed.
Speaker B:Sex dies for the same reason.
Speaker B:And the cure isn't another couple's bed, it's attention.
Speaker B:And remember that Oscar Wilde's quote at the top, One should never marry.
Speaker B:I think the movie tests that line and disagrees with it.
Speaker B:Its answer is, you can marry as long as you're willing to fall in love with a new version of the same person.
Speaker B:Now, my one critique.
Speaker B:The film diagnoses Angela's erasure brilliantly and then doesn't fully free her.
Speaker B:Her photo never gets hung.
Speaker B:Her redemption comes by joining his music at his piano in his office.
Speaker B:So the movie says women disappear inside marriage and then gives the redemptive voice to the man.
Speaker B:Is that honest realism or a blind spot?
Speaker B:I think it might be a blind spot.
Speaker B:But here's the thing about a blind spot, just like a real one.
Speaker B:The car is still there, even if you can't see it.
Speaker B:Angela's photo is still in the hallway, framed.
Speaker B:Her eye is in every room of that apartment.
Speaker B:Not being seen doesn't make her talent any less real.
Speaker B:And you Know what happens when you don't check your blind spot?
Speaker B:You crash.
Speaker B:Joe never looked over his shoulder at Angela's life.
Speaker B:And the collision came anyway, one night at a dinner party.
Speaker B:Sometimes it takes a passenger to say, hey, there's a car there.
Speaker B:That's Hawk turning the photo around.
Speaker B:And maybe the film puts Angela in Joe's blind spot, but not in ours.
Speaker B:We see her.
Speaker B:The movie makes us the ones who have to keep checking the mirror.
Speaker B:And the fix for a blind spot is.
Speaker B:Is a mirror.
Speaker B:A movie full of mirrors about a man who won't look in them.
Speaker B:Come on.
Speaker B:I left this one more hopeful than the director did.
Speaker B:I think the old relationship did die that night.
Speaker B:And something new started at that piano.
Speaker B:And the song Joe plays is Thelonious Monk's I'm confessing that I love you.
Speaker B:Wilde said the whole film was confession from everyone and that making it was therapeutic for all of them.
Speaker B:Maybe that's my own hope talking.
Speaker B:Maybe that's the softie in me, the Seth Rogen in me.
Speaker B:But I'll say this, as someone who's been Angela, I know what it's like to be the car in the blind spot.
Speaker B:And this movie saw her.
Speaker B:If you've ever felt invisible in your own home, I think this movie sees you, too.
Speaker B:My rating is four and a half out of five stars.
Speaker B:And that's the invite.
Speaker B:Thank you so much for listening and for sticking with me all the way to the end.
Speaker B:I know we went deep tonight, and I hope it made you look at this movie and maybe your own relationships a little differently.
Speaker B:Now, I want to hear from you.
Speaker B:Do you think Joe and Angela stay together?
Speaker B:Are you Team Seth?
Speaker B:They're together forever?
Speaker B:Or Team Olivia?
Speaker B:They break up but stay best friends.
Speaker B:And are Peanut and Hawk real?
Speaker B:Tell me.
Speaker B:Come argue with me in the Millennial movie Mob Facebook group.
Speaker B:It's a spoilers allowed zone, so go wild.
Speaker B:If you liked this episode, please, like, follow and subscribe and leave a review.
Speaker B:It really helps the show find more people who overthink movies on purpose.
Speaker B:And come find me on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, blue sky, and threads.
Speaker B: th anniversary of: Speaker B:And of course, a happy anniversary episode is in the works.
Speaker B:Until next time.
Speaker B:Remember, some movies stick with you.
Speaker B:So let's stick together.
Speaker A:Thank you for listening to Millennial Movie Mall.
Speaker A:We broke it it down.
Speaker A:That's our job.
Speaker A:If you enjoy what you heard, like follow and share.
Speaker A:Spread the word.
